化学类高端杂志的审稿细则
本人最近给多家杂志审稿，基本上是高分子化学类的高端杂志，IF〉3，他们的审稿要求一般如下，发出来给大家，希望对大家有所帮助。
If you recommend revision, please make your comments as constructive as possible to help the authors improve their paper. Please do not attempt to re-write the paper. It is the responsibility of the authors to produce a clear manuscript in correct English. Extensive editing and/or rephrasing is not being requested. It is helpful, however, if you can mention typographical, spelling and grammatical errors, but this is not essential.
Authors are allowed to submit only one revision and therefore your comments should be sufficiently detailed for the authors to make all necessary changes that can eventually lead to acceptance. If a revised manuscript is sent back to you the only response required will be a simple yes or no to the question, "Is the paper now suitable for publication?"
Overall recommendation:
____Accept
____Minor Revision
____Major Revision
____Major Revision Requiring Re-review
____Reject
Is the paper of sufficient originality to warrant
publication in Polymer?
YES____
NO ____
(Papers that are scientifically flawed, provide no new
insight, merely report observations
without analysis or comment, are incomplete or of
insufficient priority should be rejected)
Can the paper be shortened without detriment?
YES____
NO ____
(If yes, please indicate what can be removed in your report)
Is the paper clearly and sensibly arranged?
YES____
NO ____
(If no, but otherwise acceptable, please suggest necessary
improvements in your report)
Are the analysis and conclusions a logical outcome of the
data and
discussion?
YES____
NO ____
(If no, please state the errors clearly in your report)
In your judgement, where does this paper lie in relation to
cognate papers in primary polymer science journals?
Top 25% ____
Top 50% ____
Bottom 50% ____
Bottom 25% ____
If in the bottom 50% but you nevertheless feel that the
paper should be published in Polymer, please give brief
reasons why in the below space.
Detailed comments:
可见新是最主要的。大家切记。
[ 本帖最后由 huanghefirst 于 2006-8-24 09:45 编辑 ]
搜索更多相关主题的帖子:
化学类 细则 杂志 高分子化学 高端 化学 细则 杂志 高端 审稿
- 